Understanding withdrawal restrictions, suspensions and other consequences
aliko-aapayrollservices.com - Small businessess from 1 to 80 employees outsource your payroll management to us and let us worry about your payroll processing.
RSS Follow Become a Fan

Delivered by FeedBurner

Recent Posts

Tax changes to expect when you’re expecting
2016 Tax Tips for 2015 Filing Year
From Proprietorship to Corporation - When is the Best Time to Incorporate?
Tax Specialists Brief your Clients About CRA Fraud And E-Mail Scams
Bank of Canada cuts rates again

Most Popular Posts

Help your teenager build credit responsibly
Being an Executor of an Estate
Student Line of Credit
Principal Residence Exemption


aliko nutrition store- isotonix
aliko payroll services
canada revenue news and videos
canadian news
Cross border Tax
Disability awareness and Benefits for disabled
estate planning
Home Car Insurance
Income Splitting Strategies in Retirement
kids and money -set your children up for financial success
life insurance
on line safety tips
online safety tips
Real Estate - Investments / Retirement
Retirement planning
Save your money
small business planning
Tax Information for Students
tax news
tax planning
tax tips.ca
Tech news


January 2016
July 2015
May 2015
April 2015
February 2015
December 2014
November 2014
September 2014
August 2014
July 2014
June 2014
May 2014
April 2014
March 2014
February 2014
January 2014
December 2013
November 2013
October 2013
September 2013
August 2013
July 2013
June 2013

powered by


Understanding withdrawal restrictions, suspensions and other consequences

Understanding withdrawal restrictions, suspensions and other consequences
Understanding withdrawal restrictions, suspensions and other consequences
Posted by Jim Yih
One of the key decisions that needs to be made around Group RRSP and pension plans is whether employers want to allow employees to withdraw money from the Group retirement program.
More and more, we are seeing employers who are concerned at the high number of withdrawals being taken out of Group RRSP plans.  I’ve seen one group where 70% of the money that went into the plan came out in the same year.  In my experience, plans with withdrawal restrictions operate more effectively than those without.  Here are some examples and variations of withdrawal restrictions.
No withdrawals
The first example of a withdrawal restriction is just not allow withdrawals from the plan.   In these cases, a defined contribution pension plan would be ideal because pension legislation does not allow for withdrawals from pensions while members are employed.  Even if the member terminates, members can take their money and move it into a Locked-in Retirement Account (LIRA), but they are still limited to their ability to withdraw money.
The whole point of preventing employees from accessing their retirement funds prior to retirement is mainly to protect them from being their own worst enemies.
Some plans will take a middle ground and will allow some withdrawals but not all contributions.  An example would be a plan that allows members to withdraw their own contributions but not allow withdrawal of employer contributions.
Withdrawal suspension
Another example of a withdrawal restriction is to impose withdrawal suspensions.  A good example of this is where employer contributions will be suspended for a period of time if the employee makes a withdrawal from the plan.  Often the suspension is for 1 year.  The challenge with a withdrawal suspension is the tracking falls on the shoulders of the employer and typically the person that does payroll.  Sometimes the slightest consequence makes people think twice about pulling money out.
Withdrawal consequence
The last example of a withdrawal restriction is a withdrawal consequence (which is similar to a withdrawal suspension).  Let’s say you have a tiered plan where employer will give a 2% match for employees up to 3 years of service, 4% match for 3 to 10 years of service and 7% match for 10 years plus.  If the employee withdrawals money from the plan, they automatically drop to the lowest tier for 3 years.  That’s the consequence for taking money out of the plan.
My five cents
I believe that people always have good intentions but not always good discipline.  When we see plans with no withdrawal restrictions, suspensions or consequences, we tend to see higher withdrawals, which hurts the overall performance of the plan.
Far too many times, I’ve seen people take money out of their Group RRSP plan for vacations, cars, quads, renovations, paying off consumer debt and other modern day emergencies.
As a result, I believe that withdrawal restrictions are an important part of a successful Group retirement plan.
Jim Yih is a partner with Clearpoint Benefit Solutions who specializes in Group RRSPs and Pensions.  If you need help implementing a new plan or reviewing and existing group retirement plan, contact Jim through the Clearpoint Website.

0 Comments to Understanding withdrawal restrictions, suspensions and other consequences:

Comments RSS

Add a Comment

Your Name:
Email Address: (Required)
Make your text bigger, bold, italic and more with HTML tags. We'll show you how.
Post Comment